Nau mai -Welcome to this topic, where we continue to build on your cultural understandings and explore what is means to carry out your role as a support worker in a culturally safe manner.
Cultural Safety vs Cultural Competence
You may be familiar with the phrases cultural safety and cultural competence, but what do you think are the difference between these two concepts might be?
Mātakitaki-watch this video from Medical Council of New Zealand that highlights at the difference, then complete the post watch activity.
Video Title: Cultural Safety vs Cultural Competence
Watch Time: 2:47
Post Watch Activity: Now that you have watched the video, write your own explanation of cultural safety
Source: YouTube
The importance and benefits of cultural safety is explained in this quote from the Healthify website.
healthifyThe ultimate goal of cultural safety is to provide equitable healthcare. In Aotearoa New Zealand, attaining health equity is of particular importance to Māori. However, the provision of healthcare in a culturally safe manner is expected to provide benefits across a wide range of individuals and communities including those who are at risk of inequity due to age, gender, sexual orientation, socioeconomic status, religious belief and/or disability.
It's important to acknowledge that cultural safety is not about treating everyone the same. In fact, it's recognised that treating everyone the same makes health inequity worse, not better.
Āta whakaaro – think carefully about this quote.
Why does treating everyone the same make health inequity worse, not better? Consider what you know about the concepts of equity and equality and write down your thoughts.
Distribution of Power vs Autonomy and Self-Determination
Part of cultural safety is understanding how influence and power affects the autonomy and self-determination of tāngata and their whānau. Let’s take a look at what these words mean and how they relate to cultural safety.
Distribution of Power:
- This refers to how power is shared or controlled between individuals and between health and wellbeing organisations and clients. In support work, it involves the balance of power between support workers and tāngata whaiora, as well as between the broader organisation and tāngata whaiora
- If power is not balanced and shared, people may feel ignored or pressured into making decisions that do not align with their own preferences or needs. They may feel they have no choices and are being forced into decisions that are made for them, rather than with them. This can occur not only in interactions between support workers and tāngata whaiora but also in how organisational policies and practices affect individual care. This can lead to feelings of lack of control over their own care.
Autonomy:
- Autonomy is the right and ability of individuals to make their own choices and decisions about their care and life without pressure or influence from others. This includes individuals having the right to be fully informed about their healthcare options, including the benefits, risks, and alternatives, before making a decision.
- In a culturally safe environment, support workers and organisations respect the peoples autonomy by actively listening to individuals’ wishes and making sure their preferences are honoured without imposing external biases or cultural assumptions
Self-Determination:
- Self-determination refers to the ability of individuals to make decisions about their own lives, based on their own values, beliefs, and preferences. This includes the right to choose their own health and wellbeing providers, treatments, interventions, and to refuse any treatment they do not want.
- Culturally safe practices support self-determination by recognising and valuing each person’s cultural identity and preferences. This means support workers and organisations supporting people in making informed decisions about their care, ensuring these choices align with their values and beliefs, and empowering them to have control over their own care journey.
Rīti - Read this case study for an example of a support worker interacting in a culturally safe manner as she supports Mr Lee’s autonomy and self-determination.
Reading
Rina is a support worker at a community health organisation, supporting Mr. Lee. Mr Lee is an elderly individual from a cultural background that places significant emphasis on family decision-making. Mr. Lee has been diagnosed with a chronic illness and needs to make decisions about his treatment plan.
Mr. Lee’s family is actively involved in his care, as they prefer to be consulted before making any major decisions. Rina understands that respecting Mr. Lee’s cultural values is essential to providing culturally safe care. She must balance the distribution of power, ensure Mr. Lee’s autonomy, and support his self-determination throughout the process. To do this she carries out the following culturally safe practices:
- Rina conducted an initial assessment of Mr. Lee’s cultural and personal preferences before scheduling the meeting, ensuring she understands the importance of family involvement in his decision-making process.
- Rina is aware of and respects any family hierarchies or traditional roles that may influence the decision-making process, ensuring that the meeting is conducted in a culturally sensitive manner.
- For the scheduled family meeting, Rina ensures the family members Mr Lee wants to attend are invited
- She ensures that Mr. Lee and his family have an equal opportunity to express their opinions and preferences
- She actively listens to Mr. Lee’s and his family’s input and acknowledges their preferences and beliefs regarding treatment
- She provides them with clear, detailed information about all available treatment options, including benefits, risks, and alternatives.
- She ensures they that have answers to any questions they have to ensure they are fully informed.
- She supports Mr Lee and his family’s right to make the final decision about his care and reassures him that his preferences will be honoured.
- Rina carefully documents the meeting outcomes and the decisions made, ensuring that Mr. Lee’s and his family’s preferences are accurately recorded and communicated to those involved in his care.
Now we have discussed what cultural safety is, continue on to our next section to explore more about culturally safe practices for support workers.
Culturally safe practices are essential to providing high-quality, effective care and support. They are ensure tāngata whaiora and their whānau receive care that acknowledges and respects their individual cultural values and needs. When people feel that their cultural identity is acknowledged and respected, they are more likely to use and benefit from health and wellbeing services. If they don’t feel safe about using these services they won’t use them, and their health could deteriorate.
Culturally safe practices encompass several key elements:
- Awareness of cultural diversity: This involves understanding and respecting the diverse cultural values and principles of tāngata whaiora and their whānau, recognising how cultural traditions shape care preferences and expectations.
- Focusing on the individual needs of tāngata whaiora and their whānau: This involves providing care that is person-centred and tailored to the specific needs and preferences of individuals, ensuring that their cultural values and personal preferences are integrated into their care plan.
- Awareness of own bias: This involves health and wellbeing workers being aware of their own biases, attitudes, and assumptions. These personal biases can affect the quality of care and interactions with the people they support.
- Awareness of institutional bias: This involves health and wellbeing organisations reflecting on their own cultural practices and policies to ensure they do not disadvantage or exclude any group.
By incorporating these culturally safe practices, support workers and organisations can create a more inclusive and respectful environment.
In the following sections, we will explore how understanding and addressing biases is integral to maintaining cultural safety in your practice.
Understanding bias is a strategy for ensuring culturally safety. As a support worker this culturally safe practice is crucial for contributing to a professional, safe and inclusive environment within your health and wellbeing organisation.
What is Bias?
Bias refers to a tendency or preference for or against a particular person, group, way of thinking or thing, often resulting in unfair judgment or discrimination.
Bias can be personal or institutional.
- Personal bias: The individual prejudices, thoughts and feelings that affect how we perceive and interact with others. These biases are shaped by personal experiences, beliefs, and values. They influence our behaviours, decisions and actions.
- Institutional bias: The ingrained and established practices within organisations and institutions that reinforce inequality and disadvantage certain groups. This type of bias is seen in policies, procedures, and behaviours that favour one group over others, leading to unequal treatment and opportunities.
Examples of bias include the following:
- Cultural bias
Personal: This might lead someone to misinterpret behaviours and traditions different from their own as strange or inferior
Institutional: practices or polices that favour one cultural group over others, leading to unequal opportunities and resources or the development of services that do not consider the needs of diverse cultural groups. - Sexual orientation
Personal: This bias can manifest in the form of homophobia or personal assumptions about sexuality leading to unfair treatment or exclusion of LGBTQ+ individuals.
Institutional: Laws or organisational policies that discriminate against LGBTQ+ individuals such as lack of inclusive health benefits or discrimination in hiring practices - Gender bias
Personal: This often results in stereotyping roles and abilities based on gender, affecting how individuals are perceived and treated.
Institutional: Practices that favour one gender over another, affecting hiring, promotion, pay and underrepresentation in leadership roles. - Religious bias
Personal: This might lead to prejudice against individuals who practice a different faith, spiritual belief system or no faith at all.
Institutional: Policies or practices that fail to accommodate religious practices or discriminate against individuals based on their religious beliefs, such as not providing flexible leave for religious observances. - Socio-economic status bias
Personal: Assumptions about a person’s capabilities or character based on their financial situation, leading to unfair judgments or discrimination.
Institutional: Practices that disadvantage individuals from lower socio-economic backgrounds, such as barriers to accessing services, limited support for educational advancement, or biased bank loan approval processes. - Age bias
Personal: Involves assuming individuals of certain ages are less capable, resistant to change, or have diminished intelligence or value. This can lead to expectations that people of certain ages should behave in stereotypical ways or be capable of only certain things
Institutional: Policies or practices that disadvantage individuals based on their age such as hiring practices, promotions, or training opportunities - Disability bias
Personal: Assuming individuals with disabilities are less competent, overly focusing on their limitations rather than their abilities, or feeling pity instead of recognising their autonomy and potential.
Institutional: Practices that do not adequately accommodate or support individuals with disabilities, such as inaccessible workplaces or lack of reasonable adjustments in job roles. - Mental Illness bias
Personal: This leads to stereotyping individuals with mental illnesses as being dangerous, unreliable, less intelligent or incapable of making decisions
Institutional: Policies that fail to support mental health needs, such as inadequate mental health resources, lack of accommodations, or discriminatory practices in employment and health service provisions.
Reflection
Reflect on the examples of personal and institutional bias that you have just read.
- Have you personally experienced any of these biases?
- How did it affect your feelings, actions, or sense of self?
- Has this experience shaped your views and interactions with others-if so, in what ways?
- Have you observed others experiencing any of these biases?
- How did you respond to the situation?
- What emotions did you notice in those who were affected, and how did it impact their behaviour or wellbeing?
It would be useful to write your responses and keep them as a private reflection to deepen your understanding of bias.
Becoming aware of how bias presents itself allows you to be more intentional and empathetic in your support work, ensuring you contribute to a fairer and more culturally safe environment.
Types of Bias
There are various types of personal and institutional bias, including:
Explicit Bias:
- Explicit bias is the conscious belief, attitude, or stereotype toward a specific person, group, or thing. It is intentional and can be openly shown or stated.
- Example: A support worker consciously avoids assigning a particular task to a person from a specific ethnic group because they believe that group is less likely to adhere to treatment plans. This behaviour is deliberate and based on a conscious stereotype.
Implicit Bias:
- Implicit bias refers to the automatic attitudes or stereotypes that influence our understanding, actions, and decisions without us being aware of them. These biases are not intentional and often go against our conscious beliefs.
- Example: A support worker unintentionally spends more time and shows more warmth towards tāngata who share their own cultural background, while being less engaged with patients from different cultures. This happens without the support worker's awareness and contradicts their belief in treating all patients equally.
Unconscious Bias:
- Unconscious bias, which is similar to implicit bias, refers to the automatic judgments and stereotypes we form about certain groups of people without even realising it. Everyone has these biases because our brains naturally categorise people and things to make sense of the world.
- Example: A support worker unknowingly assumes that a younger patient is less knowledgeable about their condition and, as a result, provides overly simplistic explanations. This judgment occurs automatically and without conscious intent, stemming from a subconscious stereotype about age and the ability to understand health information.
Our biases can significantly influence how we interact with others and the way we approach our work. This can impact the quality of care and the experiences of those we support.
Read and flip the cards to better understand how bias can influence as support worker
H5P here
Becoming aware of your own biases is a key component of practising cultural safety. As we discussed earlier, biases—whether implicit, explicit, or unconscious—can shape the way you interact with tāngata whaiora (people seeking health support), colleagues, and others in your workplace. When you actively work on recognising and addressing your biases, you enhance the quality of care and contribute to a more inclusive and equitable environment for everyone.
Reflection
Reflect on your current understanding of cultural safety and personal biases. In your reflection, consider the following:
- What strategies could a support worker use to become more aware of their own biases? Think about methods such as self-reflection.
- How can increasing this awareness positively influence your practice?
Consider the impact on the relationships you build, the quality of care you provide, and the inclusiveness of your approach.
Write down your strategies and ideas to create a personal guide that you can revisit as you continue to develop culturally safe practice.
Hopefully, you were able to come up with some useful strategies in the previous reflection activity. Now, let’s take a look at a list of strategies designed to help you uncover and address any potential biases that could affect your interactions with the people you work with. Click on each section below to expand and read more about each strategy.
- Regularly reflect on your thoughts, behaviours, and decisions. Consider how your cultural background, upbringing, and personal experiences may influence your perceptions and actions. Ask Yourself Questions such as:
- "Why do I feel this way about a particular group?"
- "Am I making assumptions based on stereotypes?"
- “What assumptions do I make about people from different cultures or backgrounds?”
- “Are there certain groups I feel more comfortable working with than others?”
- Think about situations where you might have acted based on assumptions or stereotypes. Analyse how these biases might have affected the outcome and how you can do better in the future.
- Keep a journal to document your thoughts, experiences, and any situations where you felt your biases might have influenced your decisions. Reviewing these entries over time can help you track patterns and progress in your awareness.
- Talk to your peers or supervisors about your interactions with clients. Others may notice biases that you're unaware of. Ask for feedback on how you handle diverse situations and be open to constructive criticism.
- Participate in workshops, seminars, or courses on cultural competence and bias awareness. Continuous learning can help you stay informed about how biases develop and how they can be minimised.
- Take the initiative to learn about the cultures. Read articles, books, and research studies on bias and its effects in the healthcare field. The more informed you are, the better equipped you’ll be to manage your biases.
- Build relationships with people from different cultural, ethnic, and social backgrounds. Direct interaction can challenge stereotypes and reduce biases.
- Engage in meaningful conversations about culture, identity, and experiences to deepen your understanding of others.
- Develop mindfulness practices to help you remain aware of your automatic thoughts, emotions, reactions and judgments. This can include pausing to reflect before making decisions or interacting with clients and asking yourself questions like "Am I being fair?, "What assumptions am I making?". This can help you recognise when a bias is influencing your behaviour.
- When you notice a biased thought, consciously replace it with a more objective or inclusive perspective.
- Choose words that are respectful and inclusive of all cultures, identities, and abilities. Language evolves over time, and terms that were once acceptable may now be outdated or considered inappropriate. Stay informed about these changes to ensure the language you use aligns with current, inclusive practices.
- Practice active listening by engaging fully with what clients are saying without pre-judgment. This means listening to understand, rather than to respond, and being open to their experiences and viewpoints.
- Set a mindful intention to approach your work with openness, curiosity, and respect. This can help ground you in your commitment to cultural safety.
- Recognise that you do not know everything about every culture and that your understanding may be limited. Approach each interaction with a willingness to learn.
- Accept that cultural knowledge is vast and ever-changing and remain open to new information and perspectives.
- Collaborate with colleagues, cultural advisors, or community leaders who may have more knowledge or experience. This can help you provide better support while also expanding your own cultural knowledge.
- Don’t hesitate to ask questions when you encounter something unfamiliar. Showing curiosity and a desire to learn demonstrates respect and a commitment to providing culturally appropriate care.
What did you think of those strategies? Did they align with some of the ideas you came up with during your reflection, or did they spark new thoughts? If you have strategies that weren’t mentioned, consider sharing them with your classmates and listening to their suggestions. Collaborative learning is a great way to deepen your understanding and continue building your skills in culturally safe practices.
End of Topic
Well done on completing this topic! We've covered key concepts around cultural safety and explored how you, as a support worker, can practice in a way that honours and respects cultural differences. Building this awareness is essential for creating trusting and inclusive environments for those you support. In the next topic, we’ll dive into another crucial area—interpersonal skills and relationship-building. These skills are fundamental to effective support work and will help you connect meaningfully with tāngata whaiora and their whānau. Keep up the great work and let’s continue building on these foundations!